News and Links: January 26, 2015

The latest batch of news and links from education blogs/websites:

I know we have pretty good eye care through the district, but I think I’m going to complain about the quality of my eyeglass prescription. Because when I went to the other day it actually looked like one of their editors wrote a piece acknowledging that FACTORS OTHER THAN “BAD” TEACHERS might be to blame for some students under-performing. 

Two recent articles help to disprove the myth that won’t die: that our public schools are failing:

With Jeb Bush looking like a strong contender for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, here’s a look at his record on education.

When we talk about how the reform agenda is taking the joy out of learning, this argument is often received as the kind of soft, anti-competitive coddling that is weakening our students. This article, from The Atlantic, articulates a sound rationale for why we need to bring joy back.

Not only is this a dreary and awful way to treat children, it makes no sense educationally. Decades of research have shown that in order to acquire skills and real knowledge in school, kids need to want to learn. You can force a child to stay in his or her seat, fill out a worksheet, or practice division. But you can’t force a person to think carefully, enjoy books, digest complex information, or develop a taste for learning. To make that happen, you have to help the child find pleasure in learning—to see school as a source of joy.

Recently we posted an article about a report saying that the requirement for kids to read by the end of kindergarten may be harmful to sum.  Here’s a piece by a pre-K teacher talking about her experience.

I know you never get tired of hearing our Governor trashing us, but here’s some more comments he made last Thursday. On the plus side, he is at least spreading the love by showing his contempt for the general public as well, noting that the real problem is that they’re too stupid to understand what’s going on:

“If (the public) understood what was happening with education to their children, there would be an outrage in this city,” Cuomo said. “I’m telling you, they would take City Hall down brick by brick.“It’s only because it’s complicated that people don’t get it.”

A couple of updates

  • We mentioned yesterday that the Senate seems to be leaning away from maintaining the testing requirement, and that two house members introduced a bill to end federally mandated testing. However, John Kline, the head of the House Education Committee, continues to support federal testing requirements, albeit with less US government involvement in consequences.
  • We also mentioned yesterday that Cuomo’s agenda will be in the hands of the legislature. Today, Sheldon Silver, Speaker of the New York State Assembly, was arrested on corruption charges. It is too early to tell exactly what this will mean – but Silver has been a supporter of unions and is opposed to much of Cuomo’s agenda. If he resigns or is forced out if convicted, his replacement is likely to be someone in Cuomo’s pocket.
  • As noted, under the Governor’s plan only 50% of a teacher’s evaluation would be based on observations, with one of two observations being conducted by an outside “expert.” But things are actually WORSE THAN THAT. The school administrator’s observation would count for 15% of the score while the outsider’s rating would count for 35%. 
  • Don’t forget to send your comments about testing to:
  • The link to Peter Greene’s post that features some other teacher’s letters posted in the comment section had a bad link. It has been corrected on the original post, and you can get there by clicking here

Boosting Social Studies

One of the earliest complaints about federal testing mandates (and still a very valid one) is that the focus on ELA and Math has crowded out valuable instruction in other areas, such as the arts and humanities. In this vein, the National Council for the Social Studies is pushing to have a provision added to the ESEA “establishing a competitive grant program that will support innovative, research-based approaches to civic learning, history, geography and economics,… for low-income elementary school and secondary school students…” Read the whole letter and take action by clicking here. (Thanks to Ruth Squillace for the link).

Good News, Bad News, and a Meeting

A little heads up. When you get to number 3 below, you may be really tempted to throw in the towel, shut your door, and just pray you make it to retirement. All I can say is that when you get to work tomorrow, please take a look at your students and remember that, ultimately, they are the reason we need to keep fighting.
1) On February 23rd there will be a general membership meeting. Lucille asked that everyone please make every effort to attend. It will be 3:15 at the High School Library.
2) Senate hearings began today on the re-authorization of NCLB. During the hearing, Chairman Lamar Alexander quoted New York principal Carol Burris on the topic of local control. The committee also heard testimony from, amazingly, a PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER(!). The quote from Ms. Burris (an outspoken opponent of the current standardized testing program) and the teacher’s testimony (again, strongly against standardized testing), are further confirmation of the direction that the committee is leaning.

In a related story, Congressman Chris Gibson (R-NY) and Congresswoman Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ)have introduced a bill to “banish federally mandated annual testing.”

On this particular fight, the momentum is currently in our favor, but it’s not over – THIS BATTLE IS OURS TO LOSE. Sen. Alexander has stated that many of his constituents have come out strongly against testing, but don’t doubt for a minute that lobbyists for the testing industry and charter schools won’t be fighting to keep testing in place. We must make sure our voices are heard.
Of course, even if federal mandates are eliminated, it will be up to NYSED to decide what happens here. And that’s not looking very promising.
3) In his state of the State address today, Governor Cuomo upped the ante even further in his all out war against public school teachers.
  • Only a few weeks after suggesting that state test scores should account for 40% of a teacher’s evaluation, Cuomo is now recommending that standardized tests comprise 50% of a teacher’s score.
  • Even the 50% figure is misleading, as a teacher rated ineffective on test scores would be considered ineffective, regardless of their observations, meaning that that teachers will be essentially graded 100% by test scores.
  • Local control of evaluations would be replaced by scoring bands set at the state level.
  • Evaluations would require two observations, one of which would be conducted by someone from outside the district, such as a SUNY professor or an “independent” evaluator from a list provided by the state.
  • He wants to increase the cap on charter schools (something that will be necessary if the state is to follow through on the recommendation in the Regents’ letter that under-performing public schools be closed and replaced)
  • Tenure would become “renewable” and requirements increased to 5 years
  • An additional $1.2 Billion of school aid was proposed, conditional on acceptance of the aforementioned “reforms,” thus pitting teaches against communities. 
The governor will be aggressively pushing this agenda, but none of it can come to fruition without the legislature, so we MUST LET OUR LAWMAKERS KNOW that these changes will cause great harm to public education and do lasting damage to our children.

News and Links: January 22, 2015

Another assortment of important news items and links from education blogs and web sites:

In an incredibly gutsy move, Comsewogue science teacher and  PJSTA President Beth Dimino has become the first local teacher to publicly announce that she is refusing to administer the state tests this year. Will others follow?  Ms. Diminio has the support of her Superintendent, Dr. Rella, How this will pan out in terms of the state’s reaction is still anyone’s guess.
Also on the refusing tests front, the Comsewogue school district is taking a stand against field testing. Again will others follow?
In a Newsday OpEd piece, Pat Med Supt. Mike Hynes looks back at the “Nation at Risk” report and how far we have strayed from the recommendations of that report (and from common sense). 
A new poll shows that only 1/3 of New Yorkers support the Common Core, while just about half oppose it. And while Cuomo has roughly 50/50 approval ratings, only 18% trust his leadership on education issues. 
While we’re very familiar with all the studies showing how the US is falling behind, here’s a report that puts it all in context through a much more realistic and broad look at the relevant data. 
video released by the Alliance for Quality Education, released prior to the state of the state, rips into the Governor on the issues of equity and the reform agenda.
Also on the topic of equity, while a recent post pointed out the growing gaps in the US and in New York State. a new report shows that the gap between rich and poor districts is growing especially fast on Long Island.
From the department of “wouldn’t that be nice,” the new governor of Pennsylvania selected a veteran educator as the Commissioner of Education. 
Research suggests that writing about yourself “can lead to behavioral changes and improve happiness.” Take that, David Coleman 
The always excellent Perdido Street School Blog reveals the truth about Cuomo’s “progressive” credentials
Feeling like a crappy teacher? You’re not alone. If nothing else it might help to understand just why so many of us feel this way.
We all too often find ourselves needing to comfort children dealing with loss. Here’s a website that offers suggestions to help these students cope with their grief.

NCLB Feedback

As previously noted, the time is now for everyone with an interest in public education (i.e. everyone) to contact Senate Education Committee chair Lamar Alexander about the reauthorization of NCLB. ( If you’re struggling with what to say in your email, here is a selection of links on the topic to give you some ammo. Take what you want from them, or just copy and paste a link and ask Sen Alexander to read it and share it with the committee.
Here’s Carol Burris’ open letter to Sen. Alexander about the faults with, and fixes for, NCLB. 
A post from AFT President Randi Weingarten reminds us of the background of the ESEA, which was overhauled by NCLB. “The law was designed to ensure that every school got the resources to teach students, particularly in neighborhoods or districts that were not wealthy… No Child Left Behind has failed to accomplish its goals, and its only real legacy is a standardized testing regime that’s squeezing the joy of learning from our schools.”  
This video of linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, and political commentator Noam Chomsky covers a lot of ground and really digs into the insidiousness of standardized testing.
An NEA Survey reveals ever declining morale among teachers and the fact that almost half of America’s teachers have thought about leaving the profession due to standardized testing. 
Even as Jay Matthews of The Washington Post asserts that  “it is difficult to argue that teachers should not be measured, at least in part, on how well their students are doing,” his column highlights the folly of tying teacher evaluations to the current testing regimen.
To see how some other folks are framing their comments to the Senate Ed. Committee, check out the comments on Peter Greene’s blog post
Sticking with Curmuducation, here’s another post from Peter Greene listing the standard defenses of annual testing and why they all collapse under scrutiny.
Finally, when you send your letter, consider posting it as a comment below to help others generate ideas.
Remember, send your comments to and remind everyone you know to do the same.

News and Links

Here’s our weekly-ish collection of news and links from the education blogs/websites/etc:

Following up on our previous post about the letters between the Governor’s office and the Regents, The Riverhead Times Review published an article by SWR Superintendent. Dr. Cohen showing the Tisch letter for what it is – a further assault on democracy in public education, and the Stronger Together Caucus published a response on their website.

On December 31st, in an effort to reinforce his anti-union agenda, Governor Cuomo made the audacious, and completely false, claim that “we have teachers that have been found guilty of sexually abusing students who we can’t get out of the classroom.” This is not the first time this trope has been trotted out, but it’s such an effective method of demonizing the teachers’ unions, that liars like CuomoMichelle Rhee, and Campbell Brown, just can’t help themselves. The truth is simply this: Teachers who are charged with sexual misconduct are automatically suspended without pay. If a teacher is convicted of sexual misconduct it is mandatory that they will be terminated. Even if unions wanted to defend pedophiles – which they do not – there isn’t even an opportunity for them to do so.

new report suggests that the Common Core requirement that all students read by the end of kindergarten may be harmful.

Probably nothing here you don’t already know, but maybe some good ammo for your next debate: From Edutopia, 8 Myths That Undermine Educational Effectiveness

Possibly the most depressing news of the week: The Majority of U.S. public school students are now living in poverty.

Close to home, the divide between rich and poor schools has grown even wider under Cuomo’s watch. This blog post details how Cuomo has deflected his failure to fund education by blaming teachers. It also provides a great history lesson on school funding in New York State.

To end on a happy note, SWR grad Eric Lopez won over 2 of the 3 judges on American Idol to earn a trip to Hollywood, If you missed the show, you can watch his audition here (thanks to Danielle Algiere for the link)


This Wednesday, the Senate Education Committee will begin hearings on the re authorization and/or revision of No Child Left Behind.  One of the biggest issues is whether or not to maintain the federal mandate for annual testing.

Committee chairman Lamar Alexander is asking for public input and has set up an email account for citizens to send in their comments:

This is a critical moment and it is absolutely essential that EVERYONE take a moment to respond. As Peter Greene wrote on his Curmuducation blog, “You do not have to be brilliant or super-articulate. Just speak from the heart. Don’t write Moby Dick in email form. Keep it brief (aka “readable”) and if you have a lot more to say, send several emails. If you just have a sentence or two and can’t figure out how to add to that, just send that. If you’ve read something that really said it for you, email a link to the piece and write ‘Read this. I believe it’s true.'”

This is sound advice, but we need to go one step further. Writing your own email is great. Writing a few is even better. But that’s still not enough. Now is the time to apply pressure to your colleagues, your family, your friends, etc, etc, and get them to send emails as well. Post this on Facebook, Twitter, Google+. Send emails to everyone you know – especially folks around the country. The ONLY way to counter the tremendous influence of corporations and lobbyists is through an overwhelming public outcry.

As Greene writes: “This is the biggest opportunity we’ve had to be heard in the education debates since the federal government first stuck their nose in. We have no excuse not to use it, and shame on us if we don’t.”

Send your email now:

The Case Against Tenure

Oral arguments began this week in the “Wright vs. New York” case. This is the case in which the plaintiffs are trying to show that tenure laws violate students’ right to a sound basic education. If the results follow the Vergara verdict in California (currently being appealed), tenure protection could be stripped from all teachers in New York State.

This interview, with attorney Rich Cassagrande, does a great job of countering the plaintiff’s claims, explaining what tenure really is and showing how it benefits not just teachers, but students themselves. If you’ve ever found yourself being attacked over tenure (or even having your own doubts about whether it truly is necessary, please watch the video.